Mindbody vs ASF Payment Solutions Comparison

Read this head-to-head Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions software comparison, where we place ASF Payment Solutions up against Mindbody, and see for yourself why Exercise.com is still the best choice.

Mindbody vs ASF Payment Solutions Comparison

In this comparison, we will compare and contrast three of the top fitness business software platforms – Exercise.com vs. Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions. These are three fitness business software platforms with differing features and options.

Mindbody and ASF Payment Solutions are missing a handful of features (mentioned below) that can help grow your client base, increase revenue, and manage your business operations. The Exercise.com gym management software platform, however, includes these essential features.

Let’s dive into a brief ASF Payment Solutions fitness software vs. Mindbody fitness software comparison and see how these two software companies compare to Exercise.com:


  • Overview: Mindbody is a specialized software solution for yoga studios, fitness centers, and wellness businesses, focusing on streamlining operations like scheduling, membership management, and payment processing.
  • Features: The platform offers online booking, automated marketing, staff management, reporting, and a consumer-facing app for class bookings. Mindbody also provides a marketplace for businesses to attract new clients and tools for customer engagement and retention.
  • Target Audience: Mindbody primarily caters to yoga studios, fitness centers, and wellness businesses, ideal for owners who need a comprehensive system for managing various aspects of their business.

ASF Payment Solutions

  • Overview: ASF Payment Solutions is a gym management software that focuses on payment processing and membership management for fitness clubs and gyms.
  • Features: Key features include robust payment processing options, membership management, gym check-in systems, and reporting tools. ASF also offers marketing and communication tools to help gyms retain and engage members.
  • Target Audience: The platform is mainly used by gym owners and fitness club operators who need a strong focus on payment processing and membership management.


  • Overview: Exercise.com combines the business management capabilities of Mindbody with the payment processing and membership management strengths of ASF Payment Solutions, offering a comprehensive solution for fitness professionals.
  • Features: The platform includes custom branded fitness app development, workout plan creation and delivery, client and class scheduling, payment processing, and business reporting. It also offers client engagement tools like workout and nutrition logging, progress tracking, and in-app messaging.
  • Target Audience: Exercise.com is suitable for a wide range of fitness professionals, including gym owners, personal trainers, online fitness coaches, and fitness influencers. It’s an ideal choice for those requiring an all-in-one platform to manage their fitness business, create and sell workout plans, and engage effectively with clients.
Exercise.com is simply the best. We were using three or four different apps or softwares to do what we can now do all in one with the Exercise.com platform.
Brandon Stroupe
Founder and President, APEC Sports Performance

Get a demo now!

Online Training Software: Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions

If you are trying to decide if you should choose the Mindbody software platform or if you should choose the ASF Payment Solutions software platform for your fitness business, it is important to consider that ASF Payment Solutions does not include all of the available options that will help expand your fitness and personal training options online – like online memberships, online workout plans, and online training.

All of these options give you a ton of flexibility to maximize your time and revenue and they’re all options that should be included in workout software built for personal trainers and gyms; fortunately, Exercise.com has you covered!

Ecommerce Software: Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions

Mindbody allows fitness businesses and fitness professionals to sell online workout plans and now offers online training and online memberships. ASF Payment Solutions does not offer any additional ecommerce features like online training, online memberships, or online workouts. The Exercise.com gym ecommerce software platform includes all of these important features to help grow and expand your reputation near and far; plus, it adds a new revenue stream to grow your business.

ASF Payment Solutions software does not have a workout creator/logger or an exercise libraryExercise.com includes both of these options, plus the ability to create custom exercises that can give your workouts a unique twist. Exercise enthusiasts are using online workouts more than ever and always have their mobile devices nearby to access mobile apps, so this is a missed opportunity if those features are not available.

Fitness Assessment Software: Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions

Motivation is a key barrier for exercisers who are trying to start or maintain fitness or physical activity programs. Workout challenges, assessments, and nutrition tracking are three features that can help improve motivation in your clients. Exercise.com offers all three options in our fitness assessment software, whereas Mindbody offers workout challenges and assessments but no nutrition, and ASF Payment Solutions does not include any of these three essential features.

For an alternative to Mindbody, read our Mindbody Alternative article where we cover the Mindbody business app, Mindbody pros and cons, Mindbody pricing, the Mindbody branded app, Mindbody software competitors, and more.

For an alternative to ASF Payment Solutions, read our ASF Payment Solutions Alternative article where we cover ASF Payment Solutions customer service, ASF Payment Solutions support, ASF Payment Solutions competitors, and more.

Needless to say, when it comes down to Exercise.com vs. Mindbody vs. ASF Payment Solutions, the Exercise.com software platform is the clear winner. Request a demo today to get started.

With Exercise.com, get a custom web and smartphone app designed for your brand with additional customization available throughout your custom-built software. Grow your business, turn leads into clients, and increase revenue. Choose the Exercise.com Fitness Business Management Software Platform.

Get a demo now!


Getting started is easy
We offer done-for-you migration from every software platform. We are fully HIPAA compliant and our payments infrastructure is PCI Level 1 compliant—your clients payment, package, and other data will all be imported. It’s simple, secure, and easy to start now.
Our team of experts will migrate your data!
HIPAA Compliant
PCI Level 1
Fitness has changed.
Shouldn't your software?
The all-in-one platform powering the next generation of fitness businesses.
Gym KPI Dashboard
We make fitness businesses happy and successful. We are a next-generation software platform dedicated to making it easy for fitness professionals to manage their entire fitness business in one place.
Follow us:
Start Here
Copyright © 2024 Exercise.com
Made with ❤️ at 15310 Amberly Dr, Suite 250, Tampa, FL 33647 & world-wide
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service